In his lengthy dissertation on the importance of public opinion to decision making in government, Garry Gamble is apparently attempting to convince us of the legitimacy of the tax survey distributed to many of our residents. In his article he states, “Ideally, the people who prepare surveys and carry them out have no mission other than the objective and systematic measurement of public opinion.” Unfortunately, it is clear that Mr. Gamble and the authors of the survey have a mission and are far from objective with regard to taxation in Cook County.
One need not look beyond the cover letter that accompanies this survey to recognize the inherent bias. Under the heading of “why the survey is being conducted,” the letter details last year’s proposed and actual increases and possible proposed increases for this year along with loaded phrases such as “out of control.”
The putative “objective and systematic” survey itself takes aim at county administrator Jeff Cadwell, the county board, and hot-button issues such as the proposed daycare facility and funding for the YMCA. Bias can also be ascertained by what has been omitted. Surely an objective and systematic survey would also field questions about more popular and universally accepted government services provided by the county.
Opinions about taxation are not likely to be favorable. People don’t enjoy paying taxes. What we as citizens need in order to form our opinions is a clear, unbiased, and factual explanation of the issues related to the need for an increase in the levy. While I agree with Mr. Gamble that public opinion has a role in shaping political discourse, I am convinced the results of this survey will not provide an objective and systematic measure of public opinion. Unfortunately, this survey is intended to sway public opinion, not to inform our elected officials.
Chuck Viren
Grand Marais
Leave a Reply