In response to three recent letters to the editor:
To Chuck Flickinger, August 7, 2010
You ask what authority? Freethinkers/atheists rely on science, reason, and its methods, not a singular authority. No tyranny! New findings can amend an accumulative body of knowledge. An authoritarian Biblical position can be resistive to the discoveries made using science and reason.
Eyewitnesses? Recent evidence demonstrates that even competent, well-meaning eyewitnesses can be totally incorrect. This is significant for our justice system as no one wants to incarcerate the wrong person due to a fallible eyewitness. Shouldn’t this also be a consideration when reading of supposed eyewitness accounts of historical events?
To Monica Hussey-Klanderud, August 21, 2010
Yes, serious Biblical investigation should include “consideration of context,” also archeological evidence, political influences, and concurrent writings of the day. Bible scholars give insight and perspective. It seems that with its multiple unknown authors and translations, the Bible is an excellent example of “second-hand information” similar to playing “telephone” that you described.
To Linda McIntire, August 7, 2010
You said, “I will hold a belief until I see or experience evidence to the contrary.” What criteria do you use to establish your beliefs? From your life experience, what would indicate to you that there is an afterlife?
To forgive someone who has wronged you and to serve others are beneficial to both persons, and certainly more healthy than retribution and revenge. A supernatural intermediary is not needed to be a benevolent human being.
I’d listen to your personal testimony, but would you also consider a different point of view? Maybe read the testimony of a former minister, Dan Barker, in his book Losing Faith in Faith.
There is satisfaction and contentment to simply be a part of the natural world. I see no advantage to a supernatural as a metaphor, intermediary, or imaginary distraction from our earthly community.
Geri Jensen
Grand Marais
Leave a Reply