In response to Chuck Flickinger’s March 27 letter Joyful Dogma.
It is not asking too much to expect sound evidence if one is seeking certainty. Atheists look for evidence, not unlike that required in science, is expected for our justice system, our medical care, for automotive safety, etc. If and when there is evidence of a supernatural god, atheists could become theists! “Dogma” is for religions; no evidence is required!
Flickinger mentions Flavius Josephus, a respected first century historian. He spoke of James, the brother of the Jesus who did wonderful works. Josephus did not deify Jesus.
Jesus gave some sound advice about living peacefully together. He promoted generosity, humility, disregarded barriers of race, financial status, health status, and nationality. One may respect his disregard for some of the rules and laws of that time.
At the same time we may justifiably question Jesus’ instructions to leave families behind, to sell all material possessions to focus solely on him. It sounds too similar to cults which demand separation from family support and unquestioning submission to a selfglorified leader. And don’t skip Jesus’ proclamation that evil spirits cause convulsions and seizures, with prayer as the only solution, and there’s more.
Flickinger wonders how to establish right and wrong without “God”.
Men have always made the rules. It is men who say what the gods demand. It can change over time, and from culture to culture. Do you believe an almighty “God” is responsible for all the rules/ laws of the Bible’s Old Testament? I have never heard of right or wrong based on “convenience” as Flickinger suggested. Cultures usually come to some consensus as to decorum, the conduct desired for community and establish rules for right or wrong. Pasting a god’s authorship to it gives the rules extra clout.
And finally, ah yes, I will live happily somewhere on this earth until I die, the same as every other animal, and plant. Eventually I expect to become dusty compost. If the past is an indication of the future, so will everyone else. Life is good! Enjoy it!
Lou Jenson
Grand Marais
Leave a Reply